Both apps can keep a personal notebook running without a compulsory subscription. The more useful choice is how you want to manage that notebook: an app-managed collection with import and export tools, or a folder of Markdown files that other programs can edit directly. Compare the storage model, your actual devices and the work involved in moving out again before paying for synchronization.
Editorial review 3 Oct 2026 · Based on vendor documentation · Recommendations are editorial interpretation
Choose Joplin when notebook organization and an Evernote import route fit your archive. Choose Obsidian when direct access to ordinary Markdown files is a firm requirement. Both offer free local use. Cloud sync is a separate decision, with different storage limits and currencies. This is a documentation comparison, not a matched speed or reliability test.
Based on the documented differences below. Your priorities can change the choice.
What will your offer actually cost?Compare your regional prices over 12 months.
Enter the offers you see at checkout. These are your estimates, separate from our sourced prices above. Use the same currency and region for every offer. This worksheet supports monthly bills, annual bills and purchases that cover the full year. Day-based passes and introductory rates need their actual renewal schedule checked separately.
The scenario starts with a payment today and assumes 12 months of use at the same entered price, including any renewal. Monthly extras repeat 12 times; one-time extras are counted once. It excludes discounts, price changes, refunds, cancellation fees and anything you have not entered. Amounts are rounded to the currency’s usual precision. Confirm the actual charge and contract with the vendor.
Entries stay in this page while it is open. They are not saved or included in shared links.
The details, side by side
13 features
Row headings group related topics. Each answer keeps its specific scope. An unverified answer means we do not have enough evidence.
Platforms
Joplin
Devices
Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS and Android; Cloud plans also include a web app.
Imagine closing the app for a year and then needing one important note. In Obsidian, the text already exists as a Markdown file inside your vault. Joplin provides explicit export routes: JEX is intended for a Joplin restore, while readable exports serve a different purpose. Neither choice removes the need to preserve attachments and test a recovery. If external file tools are central to your work, Obsidian's storage model is a concrete advantage. If you prefer managing notebooks inside one application, a deliberate Joplin export routine may be enough. These are workflow judgments, not measurements of which application is easier for every reader.
Free local use is different from free multi-device service
Joplin's core application is free and open source. Obsidian is free for personal and commercial use without a required account; its commercial support license is optional. A person using one computer may therefore have no compulsory app subscription with either choice. Once you need another device, list the sync route and any storage service separately. Do not count a cloud plan you already pay for as automatically compatible, or treat the word free as a promise that support, hosting and every add-on cost nothing. Compare the actual setup you intend to maintain rather than the largest advertised feature bundle.
Joplin Cloud Basic lists €2.99 month to month or €28.69 for a year, with 2 GB of storage and a 10 MB note or attachment limit. Obsidian Sync Standard lists US$5 monthly or US$4 per month billed annually, equivalent to US$48 for that year, with 1 GB and a 5 MB file limit. These are different currencies and commitments, so this is not a converted cheapest-plan ranking. An 8 MB scan fits the documented Basic item ceiling but exceeds Standard's file ceiling. Check your largest actual attachment before comparing totals. Bigger plans exist, but buying more storage does not establish that a mobile workflow will work well.
Separate keeping notes locally from protecting a sync copy
Local storage and encrypted synchronization answer different questions. Obsidian states that local-only data is not sent to its server; official Sync adds an encrypted remote service. Joplin supports end-to-end encryption, but it needs to be enabled on one device before the others receive that setup through sync. This guide has not audited either encryption implementation or tested a lost-device scenario. Keep device access, recovery information and third-party plugins in your decision. A privacy preference can favor a local workflow without justifying an unsupported claim that one app is secure against every threat.
Try the difficult migration examples before the whole archive
Joplin's ENEX importer documents changes to complex formatting and uncertainty when restoring some internal links. Our separate three-note synthetic fixture preserved its PNG bytes and basic content, but that narrow result is not a full Evernote migration or an Obsidian comparison. For a new trial, choose a table, an attachment, two cross-linked notes and any formatting that carries meaning. For Obsidian, check whether your existing export really produces usable files and attachment paths. A file extension alone cannot establish that every app-specific behavior survives. Keep an untouched source archive until you can retrieve the information you actually need.
A personal notebook shortlist can fail when a second person needs to edit it. Joplin Cloud Basic can participate in a shared notebook but cannot start a notebook share; Pro can. Obsidian's shared vaults require an active Sync subscription for each collaborator and do not provide live co-editing on the same file or fine-grained permissions. If your real task is a tightly controlled team workspace, evaluate that task directly instead of assuming a paid sync account provides it. For a personal archive, avoid letting collaboration features you will never use decide the purchase.
Try one disposable notebook or vault before transferring a permanent collection. Write a note, attach a small file, link two notes and create a separate recoverable copy. Then reopen that copy using the intended recovery route. This is a proposed checklist rather than a claim that we completed a matched trial in both apps. Choose Joplin if its notebook and import model resolves your actual problem. Choose Obsidian if working directly with files makes ongoing retrieval and reuse simpler. Revisit the sync purchase only after the local workflow passes your own acceptance check.
For a notebook archive with a documented Evernote import route, start with Joplin. For a working folder of Markdown files you want to edit and reuse outside the app, start with Obsidian. Both can avoid a compulsory local-app subscription. Your sync destination, attachment size and recovery routine decide the rest.
Common questions
Can I use Joplin or Obsidian without a subscription?
Yes, both support free local use. Joplin Cloud and Obsidian Sync are optional services. A separate storage provider or hosting setup can have its own costs.
Is Obsidian's paid commercial license required for work?
No. Obsidian's current license overview says commercial use is free. The paid commercial license is optional support.
Which one is better for an 8 MB attachment on the entry sync plan?
An 8 MB file exceeds Obsidian Sync Standard's 5 MB maximum. Joplin Cloud Basic lists a 10 MB note or attachment limit. This compares documented plan ceilings, not a tested mobile transfer or reliability result.
Did Software Signal test these apps against each other?
No matched Joplin-versus-Obsidian test was completed. The separate Joplin ENEX observation covers a small synthetic import and export only. This comparison uses official documentation and labels recommendations as editorial judgments.
Check the sources
Evidence used for this comparison. A checked date records when we reviewed the source, not a promise that the vendor has made no changes since.