GIMP and Photoshop both support serious image manipulation, but they organize the work differently. Current GIMP 3.2 has capabilities that older comparisons omit. A fair decision considers your operating system, working files, output requirements and revision process instead of reducing the comparison to free versus paid.
Choose GIMP when an open-source desktop workflow fits the job and you can validate the handoff. Choose Photoshop when a specific Adobe capability or client requirement justifies the subscription. Keep GIMP's native XCF archive separate from files exported for other applications.
Based on the documented differences below. Your priorities can change the choice.Its current release supports layered image work with no paid editing tier.
Other formats preserve only some project properties, so an exported image is not a full XCF replacement.
SourceNative Adobe editing and review workflows can avoid conversion steps.
Published prices keep their original currency and billing terms. Taxes, promotions and checkout prices can differ.
Free mobile app with optional premium features
AvailabilityApp availability varies by region
This does not include perpetual free desktop Photoshop.
SourceAnnual subscription billed monthly
AvailabilityUnited States
Includes desktop, web and mobile plus Express Premium. This is not a cancel-any-month plan.
SourceAnnual subscription paid upfront
AvailabilityUnited States
Official FAQ annual price; 100 GB cloud storage.
SourceAnnual subscription billed monthly
AvailabilityUnited States
Includes Photoshop and Lightroom; 1 TB shown in the comparison.
SourceEnter the offers you see at checkout. These are your estimates, separate from our sourced prices above. Use the same currency and region for every offer. This worksheet supports monthly bills, annual bills and purchases that cover the full year. Day-based passes and introductory rates need their actual renewal schedule checked separately.
The scenario starts with a payment today and assumes 12 months of use at the same entered price, including any renewal. Monthly extras repeat 12 times; one-time extras are counted once. It excludes discounts, price changes, refunds, cancellation fees and anything you have not entered. Amounts are rounded to the currency’s usual precision. Confirm the actual charge and contract with the vendor.
Entries stay in this page while it is open. They are not saved or included in shared links.
14 features
Row headings group related topics. Each answer keeps its specific scope. An unverified answer means we do not have enough evidence.
Local files
The desktop workflow opens local images and saves working documents as XCF.
Offline use
Installed apps can work offline after activation; periodic licensing checks and plan-dependent grace periods apply.
Working format
Save preserves the GIMP project as XCF; Export produces delivery formats. XCF does not preserve undo history.
Save choices
Save locally or to Creative Cloud. Save a Copy can produce flattened JPEG or PNG while preserving the working document.
Interchange
Other formats preserve only some project properties, so an exported image is not a full XCF replacement.
Editable objects
Embedded Smart Objects preserve source information; PSD, TIFF or PSB can retain layers while JPEG flattens them.
Free application
GIMP is free and open source without a paid editing tier.
Use for paid work
The project FAQ permits commercial work without restrictions on the kind of work produced.
Not yet verified for this product.
Current nondestructive tools
GIMP 3.2 adds link and vector layers and expands nondestructive filter workflows.
Camera RAW
The project documents darktable and RawTherapee integration for RAW processing.
Not yet verified for this product.
CMYK scope
The FAQ describes CMYK import/export through RGB storage and soft proofing rather than a native CMYK editing mode.
Not yet verified for this product.
Current release
The download page lists GIMP 3.2.6. Older 2.x comparisons do not describe the current feature set.
Not yet verified for this product.
Not yet verified for this product.
Not yet verified for this product.
AI entitlement
The Photoshop single-app offer lists 25 monthly generative credits. Larger bundles have different allowances.
Not yet verified for this product.
Local or cloud
The default save location can be set to the computer or Creative Cloud.
Not yet verified for this product.
AI Assistant availability
The current mobile page places AI Assistant beta on web and mobile and explicitly excludes desktop.
| Feature | GIMP | Adobe Photoshop |
|---|---|---|
| Platforms | Devices Official downloads cover GNU/Linux, Windows and macOS. Vendor documentedSource | Devices Desktop on Windows and macOS with separate web, phone and iPad experiences. |
| Offline use | Local files The desktop workflow opens local images and saves working documents as XCF. Vendor documentedSource | Offline use Installed apps can work offline after activation; periodic licensing checks and plan-dependent grace periods apply. Vendor documentedSource |
| Export | Working format Save preserves the GIMP project as XCF; Export produces delivery formats. XCF does not preserve undo history. Vendor documentedSource | Save choices Save locally or to Creative Cloud. Save a Copy can produce flattened JPEG or PNG while preserving the working document. Vendor documentedSource |
| Project portability | Interchange Other formats preserve only some project properties, so an exported image is not a full XCF replacement. Vendor documentedSource | Editable objects Embedded Smart Objects preserve source information; PSD, TIFF or PSB can retain layers while JPEG flattens them. Vendor documentedSource |
| Free plan limits | Free application GIMP is free and open source without a paid editing tier. Vendor documentedSource | Free scope Free mobile and iPad apps have optional premium features. Desktop pricing offers a seven-day trial rather than an ongoing free desktop plan. |
| Use for paid work | Use for paid work The project FAQ permits commercial work without restrictions on the kind of work produced. Vendor documentedSource | Not yet verified for this product. |
| Nondestructive changes | Current nondestructive tools GIMP 3.2 adds link and vector layers and expands nondestructive filter workflows. Vendor documentedSource | Nondestructive changes Adjustment layers, masks and Smart Objects support revisable image workflows. |
| Camera RAW | Camera RAW The project documents darktable and RawTherapee integration for RAW processing. Vendor documentedSource | Not yet verified for this product. |
| CMYK scope | CMYK scope The FAQ describes CMYK import/export through RGB storage and soft proofing rather than a native CMYK editing mode. Vendor documentedSource | Not yet verified for this product. |
| Current release | Current release The download page lists GIMP 3.2.6. Older 2.x comparisons do not describe the current feature set. Vendor documentedSource | Not yet verified for this product. |
| Collaboration | Not yet verified for this product. | Review and editing Share for review supports browser comments. Invite to Edit lets collaborators edit a cloud document one at a time; Photoshop warns when someone else is editing. |
| AI features | Not yet verified for this product. | AI entitlement The Photoshop single-app offer lists 25 monthly generative credits. Larger bundles have different allowances. Vendor documentedSource |
| Local or cloud | Not yet verified for this product. | Local or cloud The default save location can be set to the computer or Creative Cloud. Vendor documentedSource |
| AI Assistant availability | Not yet verified for this product. | AI Assistant availability The current mobile page places AI Assistant beta on web and mobile and explicitly excludes desktop. Vendor documentedSource |
GIMP 3.2 adds link and vector layers and expands nondestructive filter behavior. Its release notes explain how external images can update a composition and how certain layer types can be rasterized deliberately. That makes an old claim that GIMP only has destructive editing misleading. It does not prove parity with Photoshop's Smart Objects or every adjustment workflow. Compare the editing operation you need, including what happens after a revision. A feature name is less useful than understanding whether the original content remains available when you change your mind.
Source 1Source 2GIMP preserves its working image in XCF without undo history. It uses Export for delivery formats. Photoshop can save locally or to Creative Cloud with options that preserve layers and other information. If a customer requires a specific editable file, agree on that requirement before choosing an editor. A flattened preview is not a substitute for a usable source document. Keep your native project and test a copy of the handoff file in the receiving application. This research has not verified a complex XCF-to-PSD-to-XCF round-trip or promised one would be lossless.
Source 1Source 2GIMP's application is free and its project permits commercial work. Photoshop desktop uses a subscription with several bundles and commitment types. A freelancer should compare the fee with time spent repairing files, maintaining a second application or learning a required operation. Someone doing occasional personal edits may weigh those costs differently. Free access gives you room to evaluate GIMP at your own pace, while a paid editor can still be worthwhile when it fits an established pipeline. Neither conclusion requires a claim that one interface is objectively easy for everyone.
Source 1Source 2Source 3GIMP documents external RAW processing through darktable or RawTherapee. Its FAQ also distinguishes CMYK import/export and soft proofing from a native CMYK editing model. These details matter more to some photographers and print workflows than to someone making web thumbnails. Photoshop's file-saving controls include color profiles and spot colors, but a checkbox alone does not certify a finished print job. Identify the camera formats and delivery specification first. Test the exact output with the intended receiver rather than assume that broad photo-editing support covers every stage.
Source 1Source 2Both applications have workflows centered on local working files. Photoshop additionally documents browser review links and Invite to Edit for cloud documents, where collaborators edit one at a time. License activation and periodic connectivity rules still apply to the installed software. GIMP's file workflow can be organized through your own folders and backup process. That independence can suit a solo archive but does not by itself provide a managed team review system. Decide whether you need to exchange files, collect comments or edit a shared cloud document. Those are different collaboration tasks and should not be collapsed into one yes/no comparison row.
Source 1Source 2Source 3Source 4Use a disposable copy of a job you understand: isolate a subject, adjust color, add type and deliver the requested image. Then perform one realistic change request without starting over. Record missing steps and export differences rather than judging only the first visual result. Choose tutorials that match the installed GIMP generation because older instructions can describe a different interface and feature set. If your required workflow passes, expand gradually. If a handoff fails, keep the previous editor available until you understand whether the issue is a setting, a format limit or a genuine missing capability.
Source 1Source 2Source 3Source 4GIMP is a credible free desktop choice when its native workflow and exports meet the requirement. Photoshop is a practical paid choice when the Adobe pipeline itself is part of the job. File compatibility and revision work should decide.
Yes. GIMP 3.2 documents nondestructive filters plus link and vector layers. That does not imply identical behavior to every Photoshop feature.
Yes. The official FAQ permits commercial work. Separately confirm any assets and the editable file format the client requires.
Evidence used for this comparison. A checked date records when we reviewed the source, not a promise that the vendor has made no changes since.
www.gimp.org
www.gimp.org · The FAQ now confirms vector layers were introduced in GIMP 3.2. Its planned shape tool is a separate feature.
www.gimp.org
www.gimp.org
helpx.adobe.com · Adobe's 6 October guidance describes one collaborator editing at a time and a version-conflict warning when another person is editing.
www.adobe.com
www.adobe.com
helpx.adobe.com
helpx.adobe.com
www.adobe.com · Fresh US-targeted Firecrawl retrieval resolved currency. Promotional suite prices are excluded from the recorded plans.
helpx.adobe.com
helpx.adobe.com · Adobe's redirected review article still documents browser comments; the separate cloud-document article covers Invite to Edit.
Graphic design · Affinity is a serious candidate when you want local photo work without a recurring payment for the core editor. Photoshop deserves priority when a client's editable PSD requirements or an established Adobe workflow determine the handoff. Verify the actual files before switching.
Graphic design · Begin with Inkscape for scalable paths, lettering and vector artwork. Begin with GIMP for retouching, compositing and pixel-based images. Current GIMP also has vector and linked layers, so a combined workflow can be more useful than treating the applications as mutually exclusive.
Graphic design · Try Photopea for a small browser-based edit or a PSD you need to inspect. Choose Photoshop when a required Adobe workflow, detailed capability or client file handoff makes it necessary. Neither name guarantees that a complex document will behave exactly as you expect.
